Much better than cludflare and Google recapha
Looks way better than half the ads I normally see.
Thank god we have anubis
Which god? Anubis.
Im a narcissist. Im god
I am skeptical about the real level of protection that Anubis really provides.
At the end is an automated test. Meaning that any machine could easily solve it.
Most “attackers” wont bother solving it because they don’t really care. But if they would want they could. It’s sort of protection by obscurity.
The more Anubis it’s used the more we see attacks that actually equip a way to solve the challenges. Then is when Anubis up the challenge and the battle begin, between how much can Anubis up the challenge so normal users can still browse and how much cost the attacker is willing to eat.
Giving that these attackers tend to have high budgets I’m not that certain about its actual capabilities to reject a targeted ddos.
As for crawling for big data. I do think that it does nothing here. Companies willing yo scrape big amounts of data, for AI training or other purposes, have massive budgets and the electricity cost of solving the JavaScript challenges become nothing in comparison. They also doesn’t need ro deny the service so they could spread the scrape to keep the challenge low reducing the cost even more.
Once again, positive results we currently see in practice I believe that are caused just because most scrappers and ddos attackers are just blindly attacking and doesn’t really equip themselves for Anubis. Protection by obscurity. But a well equiped attacker I don’t think it would have that much trouble getting past it, specially for scrapping, or other type of bot attacks that could be slowed down.
You’re right, although my understanding is that there are a lot of poorly implemented scrapers for AI services unintentionally DDoSing websites with requests, so Anubis is more of a mitigation against those.
Yeah, seems like the problem is that fundamentally it could work by upping the difficulty a smidge making it then meaningfully expensive, but the spread between slowest edge device and high end means it’s impossible to chase that difficulty without screwing over low end device users…
Still better than this
Both have different purposes.
The Anubis challenge could be easily and cheapely solved by any JavaScript engine. It only becomes expensive for a massive number of petitions.
If for instance you would want to register a few thousand emails in a forum anubis is not going to stop anyone.
In fact I’m sceptical about really having an impact. As even when the challenge goes up in difficulty is not that expensive compared with all other cost related to these kinds of attacks or massive scrapes.
My suspicion is that most websites using Anubis see a positive impact because most crawlers and probers doesn’t take into account Anubis, so they don’t even attach a way to solve the challenge and they directly go into the “rejected by anubis” bucket. But any targeted attack I suppose would pass easily, either by doing a slow attack not to up the challenge very much, or just eating the cost. Imagine an AI company that using nuclear plants for training data, the cost of solving a few million JavaScript challenges is nothing in comparison.
As a DDOS mitigation it helps, but once again it’s just a matter of eating the cost by the attacker. And the attack will still deny some service as the challenge go up and new legit users would also need to solve harder challenges.
Perry the platypus?
+1 Anubis, cloudflare can suck mai balls
If you’re going to increase my compute to access your site, at least give me a crypto token that may or may not be worth anything
your blog does not need an anime girl web ai firewall utility
it kinda does when the web is being scraped by bots to fuel the LLMs
Unfortunately, yes it does. Unless I want it to collapse regularly.
Watch out, you’ll anger the hive mind.
Her face is the response to years of enshittification; without her, the modern browsing experience would suck much harder. Glory to Anubis!
Anubis is open source, self-hosted, doesn’t block me just because I use a VPN and the later versions work even with JavaScript disabled!
Fuck Cloudflare, long live Anubis!
How exactly is a proof of work engine suppose to run, without any JS work?
https://anubis.techaro.lol/docs/admin/configuration/challenges/metarefresh/
Apparently it just tells your browser to refresh after x seconds.
Seems utterly pointless though…
With the proof of work approach, at least it’s demanding the client consume some resources, though the ‘right’ amount is a tricky question, either it’s so trivial as to hardly matter to the scrapers, or it’s hard enough to put a dent in the scrapers’ build, but human operated low end devices are royally screwed…
Here the crawler simply schedules a resumption and moves on to other work. The crawler doesn’t need it right now and it’s free for it to wait.
That’s just protection by obscurity then. Any targeted attack could do that challenge at zero cost.
Read the docs.
I much prefer to see Anubis rather than some bullshit captcha with a grid of AI generated slop that requires 30 clicks to pass.
(Not so) fun fact: The Anubis image is itself AI slop
https://github.com/TecharoHQ/anubis/commit/3e9a93f629e9c5a69bd7fcd6613d27ce9f5231f9
The repo credits a real artist for the anubis image
https://github.com/TecharoHQ/anubis/blob/main/web/static/img/ATTRIBUTIONS.txt
funner fact: anubis itself is slop
I’ve read somewhere the main dev has comissioned an artist to redo the Anubis mascot.
You mean 30 clicks before it tells you to “please try again” for no reason.
“Prove that you’re human by solving these machine-generated puzzles that machines can solve to give us more data to train our machines, while we run a simple script in the background to verify that you’re human based on your browser’s metadata.”
I had a captcha a few days ago that was something like “click on all the pictures that go with this” with a picture of a saucepan and the grid was food items and other things.
I pointed my phone at it and asked Gemini and almost instantly it said “the potato in the top left and the carrots look the middle of the bottom row”.
While I despise the captchas from a human perspective, the fact that an LLM can solve the challenge isn’t a deal breaker. It doesn’t need to be impossible for a non-human to solve, it just has to be too expensive.
It does certainly shift the equation to stuff like proof of work since a computer can solve it anyway, might as well not annoy the human.
To keep training the captcha solving AI of course
Oh is the person riding the bicycle part of the bicycle this time? What do you want, the corner of the pedal that is just barely in the box, or the out of focus blur in the background that might be a bicycle or it might be a bear. It’s hard to tell.
I have a self bound rule to never do the multi-tile single image ones. Fuck those so much, they’re always wrong. I will refresh for as long as it takes to get a grid of smaller images that may also be hard but I at least have some better grasp over.
I’ve seen this briefly pop up while looking up linux stuff online recently. Wondered what it was, thank you Lemmy community for some enlightenment!
I love how toxic she is to corporate professionalism.
Its also perfect marketing, the software is free with the mascot hardcoded in. The official way to change it is to contribute to get an enterprise version.
The code is MIT licensed, what’s preventing you from just removing the logo/changing it with something else…
Nothing but them respectfully asking not to do this, pointing out that they will help you do it if you pay a contribution.
I love how toxic she is to corporate professionalism.
in what way?
It’s just a silly anime girl showing up on first page load. If you’re deathly afraid of seeming unprofessional, that’s gonna do your head in…
Spot on. There were some complaints recently made by people being afraid to be seen as a furry because she has ears and a tail. It’s hilarious
Oh man. Those people are so gd cringe it IS hilarious.
Not that it matters, but it’s not anime style, it’s a “western” style cartoon character. Compare it to e.g. the original Disney princesses, the proportions and style look like that, not like anime characters.
tbf it is clearly inspired by anime tho. those eyes, the skirt and the cat ears are pretty typical anime stuff
He means that many people in a corporate environment wouldn’t expect a anime girl with a magnifying glass popping up on your screen, that could reflect badly on your company. Just imagine some CEO sharing his screen in a presentation and his background is a screenshot of some hentai scene or something. It wouldn’t make you seem very professional in the eye of the other corporate people.
That’s why companies that use anubis will usually pay for the subscription so they can replace the mascot with something else.
Oh I See. Fuck that sterile corpo professional shit.
Excellent idea !
What am I missing to understand this? What is Anubis?
Beloved anti scraping/ddos tool
Take this over cloudflare any day of the week