I’ve honestly never understood the need for s3 buckets. WebDAV satisfies my needs. I’m sure there are some use cases that require S3, but for the life of me I can’t think of one off the top of my head right now.
Shit, I am actually building a webtool and thought Minio could be a good part to be a file storage in it. What’s an good alternative?
Edit: I try “garage”
There’s also SeaweedFS that I’ve used as an S3 compatible fileserver
S3 compatibility is nice I guess if you need S3 compatibility but also… why would you need that?
sshfs does everything I need and compatibility is almost native.
SSHFS is a hack and has nothing to do with the proposal of S3 compatible backends
So enlighten me then, save me from my terrible hack that is working fine for me and tell me what it DOES have to do with. I thought S3 was a remote filesystem you can use, essentially Amazon’s proprietary version of webdav where you get a http bucket you can only access with aws proprietary tools. What’s the attraction? Clearly it seems like people love it, and I am getting dunked on for asking an honest question, which feels a bit unhealthy and unpleasant for the self-hosting community.
Am I supposed to be familiar with AWS infrastructure as a prerequisite for being here?
ok, to start with, if you need a POSIX interface to the filesystem, you already have an SSH connection to that server, and don’t need much stability across multiple clients, SSHFS may do just fine. For a homelab, that is likely the case.
now, if you’re hosting a web server that needs data distributed across drives/nodes, data redundancy, and the usage is primarily programmatic, closer to a CDN’s or machine learning pipeline than a single user browsing files; then you want an S3-compatible solution. The S3 API makes it easier to plug it into your application, while allowing you to migrate to a different one - which I’m actually currently doing for a MinIO deployment at work.
Sshfs has way more overhead and doesn’t do remotely the same thing
Kubernetes storage is the reason I was looking at Minio in the past.
Sadly I only recognized it as “the thing you put in your docker compose for integration tests”.