- 1 Post
- 135 Comments
if you mean GrapheneOS, you can’t not know that GrapheneOS’s security is thanks almost in no part to SELinux
Lemmy leftists, after having the spoiler effect patiently explained to them, and how even a 2% vote for a 3rd party candidate (nowhere near enough to win) can tip the vote against the second-choice party, using 100% of their brain:
- AVincentInSpace@pawb.socialtolinuxmemes@lemmy.world•Learning Rust to make my perfect Linux programs launcher (rofi is perfect, except it isn't written in Rust)English1·10 days ago
I swear I must be the only Rustacean in the world who agrees with you. I’m embarassed to share a language of choice with these people sometimes. Yes, Rust makes it harder to write incorrect programs, but it still requires you to use your brain and besides, the process of rewriting is likely to introduce a metric shitton of bugs, especially if you vibe code it like I’ve seen a lot of people doing.
- AVincentInSpace@pawb.socialOPtomemes@lemmy.world•AI doomerism is AI company marketingEnglish1·13 days ago
No, we’re not. I need you to understand that. One of us is concerned only with things AI might hypothetically do in the future and what we need to do to prepare for that, which consists almost exclusively of taking actions that directly benefit AI companies, and the other one is concerned with the very real harms that AI is causing right here and now to real people (people who want to buy computer components; artists, creatives, and other knowledge workers who are watching their entire career paths get erased because while AI output is much shoddier than their work, it’s a lot cheaper, and their bosses don’t care about quality; people who live near the datacenters and have to put up with low water pressure, power outages, infrasound, and heat islands; people who need to look things up online and need to worry about whether the first result on noai.duckduckgo.com is a 100% AI generated website that contains no useful information; people who live on the same planet as the hundreds of coal and natural gas power plants being built to power all of those GPUs as governments around the world decide that being AI-forward is more important than their climate goals) and how much bigger all of those problems are going to get if we don’t stop (to borrow a phrase from Cory Doctorow) shoveling asbestos into the walls of our digital society.
Talking about how AI is too powerful to be left unchained is doing the companies’ marketing work for them. Did you actually read the whitepaper they published about Mythos? Did you actually read the details of what happened to HuggingFace? Do you realize how many protections that had been in place for decades had to be disabled before the mindless slop machines could accomplish anything at all?
- AVincentInSpace@pawb.socialOPtomemes@lemmy.world•AI doomerism is AI company marketingEnglish31·14 days ago
Precisely what I’m talking about.
- AVincentInSpace@pawb.socialOPtomemes@lemmy.world•AI doomerism is AI company marketingEnglish2·14 days ago
i think you’re giving AI’s capabilities a lot of credit
- AVincentInSpace@pawb.socialOPtomemes@lemmy.world•AI doomerism is AI company marketingEnglish3·14 days ago
Or alternatively: you’re watching people get sprayed by police water cannons and you’re asking the people around you not to condemn them because fire engines also exist.
- AVincentInSpace@pawb.socialOPtomemes@lemmy.world•AI doomerism is AI company marketingEnglish3·14 days ago
It’ll kill us all because some jackass deployed LLM generation code into production without reading it first and the combine harvester’s brake stopped working because a dialog box was open on the dashboard
- AVincentInSpace@pawb.socialOPtomemes@lemmy.world•AI doomerism is AI company marketingEnglish2·14 days ago
No we’re not. One of us is concerned only with things AI might hypothetically do in the future and what we need to do to prepare for that, which consists almost exclusively of taking actions that directly benefit AI companies, and the other one is concerned with the very real harms that AI is causing right here and now and how much bigger they’re going to get if we don’t stop (to borrow a phrase from Cory Doctorow) shoveling asbestos into the walls of our digital society
EDIT: parent comment was “We are the same”. I misinterpreted it. :P
- AVincentInSpace@pawb.socialOPtomemes@lemmy.world•AI doomerism is AI company marketingEnglish3·14 days ago
You worded my own meme better than me
- AVincentInSpace@pawb.socialOPtomemes@lemmy.world•AI doomerism is AI company marketingEnglish21·14 days ago
I’ve been saying this. LLMs are just turbocharged StackOverflow. People who exclusively copy paste from it should not be employed
- AVincentInSpace@pawb.socialOPtomemes@lemmy.world•AI doomerism is AI company marketingEnglish10·14 days ago
Cory Doctorow calls it “criti-hype” (a term he defines as repeating a company’s marketing material and adding “and that’s bad” at the end), but I gotta say I like this better
- AVincentInSpace@pawb.socialOPtomemes@lemmy.world•AI doomerism is AI company marketingEnglish91·14 days ago
“Ummm ackshully AI is an incredibly broad field that–” come the fuck on. You know damn well what I meant.
- AVincentInSpace@pawb.socialOPtomemes@lemmy.world•AI doomerism is AI company marketingEnglish11·14 days ago
It will never be a smart idea to use LLMs to approve PRs, no matter how good they get.
I will say this categorically. If there is not at least one human at the company who understands a piece of code, that piece of code is a liability, no matter how well it works. The reason that AI can’t replace programmers isn’t that it isn’t good enough at generating code (although I’d still argue it isn’t), it’s that even code written by humans who are no longer at the company is an unmaintainable mess to the next batch of programmers who replace them. Changes in one part of the code often affect other parts of the code in ways that are hard to predict unless you know all of it at once, and that’s something AI is really bad at spotting. Some human, somewhere, has to understand the thing, and if you’re automating the review process, sooner or later it’s gonna let a bug through and and it’s going to be borderline impossible to find.
Also, just the idea that you would trust an AI to decide what changes are good for your codebase… eugh.
- AVincentInSpace@pawb.socialOPtomemes@lemmy.world•AI doomerism is AI company marketingEnglish91·14 days ago
I feel a little of both. Though I primarily feel fear because none of the adults I talk to can see through the facade and understand that AI is currently harmful, no matter what you are using it for.
- AVincentInSpace@pawb.socialOPtomemes@lemmy.world•AI doomerism is AI company marketingEnglish13·15 days ago
Or somebody could vibecode the software that runs on a missile silo and no one notices it has a bug until the warhead goes off before it gets launched.
- AVincentInSpace@pawb.socialOPtomemes@lemmy.world•AI doomerism is AI company marketingEnglish2·15 days ago
Superhuman Intelligence might be a threat if any of the companies developing AI right now had any way that their word guessing programs could possibly simulate consciousness. The best argument I’ve heard so far that they could is “no one understands how LLMs work, and no one understands how the human brain works, so you can’t prove they’re not the same.”
Talking about superhuman intelligence now, and fretting and worrying about what we’re going to do in the future where AI is smart enough to be dangerous, ignores all of the ways AI is dangerous now, like giving wronf answers, making it almost impossible to find useful information on the internet because sites that have it are buried under AI-generated SEO slop that’s wrong half the time, consuming way more electricity and water than municipalities can afford to supply them with, the datacenter heat island effect, carbon emissions and other forms of deadly pollution from brand new power plants for AI datacenters, to say nothing of all the jobs that are being destroyed by bosses that think their customers won’t notice the change in product quality.
- AVincentInSpace@pawb.socialOPtomemes@lemmy.world•AI doomerism is AI company marketingEnglish32·15 days ago
Well, that too.
And the shredded books and the datacenters and the environmental effects, let’s not forget those.
cute, and i love the sentiment, but unless it can actually waste sam altman’s money i’m not interested.
he has changed his user name on twitter to “ram altman”. he does not care about the jokes.