Don’t hate the player. You can’t send mail with E2E encrypted headers and you can’t leave payment data and expect Proton to violate regulations and delete it.
Signal has to deal with neither of these issues.
Proton can do what it likes when it comes to messages being sent between different proton accounts. Use of meta data rich protocols like standard email, instead of, e.g., the signal protocol, is absolutely something they can be blamed for.
As is choosing operate from a jurisdiction that can comple them to collect IP addresses.
Use of meta data rich protocols like standard email, instead of, e.g., the signal protocol
Brother…its an email product though…if you can use Signal, use Signal. But it’s a different product entirely.
When my bank sends me verification info and banking statements over Signal I’ll be elated. Until then, we unfortunately have to continue dealing with email.
As is choosing operate from a jurisdiction that can comple them to collect IP addresses.
There is no such requirement. They collect them necessarily in order to function.
Brother…its an email product though…if you can use Signal, use Signal.
The point is there is no requirement for emails sent between different proton accounts to be as insecure as they are.
This is something where there are known open source solutions that are just flat out better than what proton is using, and proton just can’t be bothered. You can’t fix the whole Internet, but proton just doesn’t care enough to fix itself.
There is no such requirement. They collect them necessarily in order to function.
By default proton doesn’t log IP addresses. They’re just not needed. But when ordered to they do.
What insecurities are you referring to?
But when ordered to they do.
And your suggestion is…refusing to comply with the law?
I explained both these things in the first post you responded to.
- Using email protocols between proton accounts means they need more meta data which is then given up on a search warrant.
- If they cared about privacy they wouldn’t be based out of Switzerland. They’d pick somewhere with more privacy rights.
And I explained to you that Proton is an email service, not a chat app.
There is nowhere that has better privacy regulations than Switzerland.
…email will inherently be a lot less secure than messaging, no matter what you do.
If you truly want to be private about something, don’t email it lol
God, I wish more people used Signal
One problem with Signal is that it can be difficult to connect with someone who is on there.
I’ve run into this a couple of times myself. And I’ve had friends run into it too. We know for a fact someone is using Signal, but you can’t find them in the search, even though you have them in your contacts with the correctly formatted number.
Personally, this issue has become a stumbling block for getting people I know to use it more.
Do you have to find a person in search to be able to send them a message?
Yes, at least that’s been my experience.
Proton was legally forced to record IPs for this account (as per the linked article). Theoretically that could happen to Signal just as well if the laws allow it in their jurisdiction. There was nothing in the article about message content or metadata being handed over to authorities.
As far as I know in France you can‘t have an anonymous phone number so technically using TOR and Proton Mail you can achieve a higher level of privacy than with Signal
But Signal is legal in France, so what would be the point? There’s no need to hide that you’re using it.
Also, that wouldn’t give you a higher level of privacy. Email records a lot of metadata unencrypted: The sender, recipient, subject line, and time sent. That’s way more compromising than the fact that you’re using Signal.
Fair point, and it seems like I was wrong about the phone numbers in France. If you can use an anonymous prepaid phone number, it makes sense to use Signal + TOR. But in many European countries, even though Signal is legal, you have to provide your legal ID to get a phone number, so your Signal account is never anonymous, as opposed to a free Proton Mail address, which you can create without providing any information.
A non-anonymous Signal account still gives you more privacy than an anonymous Proton Mail account.
All Signal can tell the authorities is the fact that your phone number was used to register a Signal account, the date (and time) that happened, and the date (and time) the account last connected to the Signal servers. In a country where you’re allowed to use Signal, that information cannot hurt you.
Proton (and every “private” email provider), on the other hand, has much of that same information (when an account was registered and when it last connected to the server) plus the date and time each individual email was sent, its recipient, and its subject line. And if the email was sent to, or came from, someone who isn’t using an encrypted email provider, the authorities will know who to serve a subpoena to to find an unencrypted copy of it. (!!!) That’s all infinitely more dangerous than the knowledge that you have a Signal account. And all the authorities need to do to get it is find out your Proton Mail address.
It doesn’t make sense under any coherent threat model to use “anonymous” (that amount of metadata would eventually deanonymise you anyway) “encrypted” email instead of Signal in a country where Signal is legal. You would be making yourself less safe for no reason.
Yeah, okay, fair point. I guess it depends on the use case. For general communication, you’re absolutely right, but in the article, it said he was a climate activist, and I imagine I‘d rather use a separate anonymous email address to organise and demonstrate than an account linked to my phone number and through that to my identity.
Huh wait does using Tor actually help with mail privacy in any way? I know Tor hides pretty much as much as can be hidden about the user, but for mailing, don’t you need to give out your personal details to sign up regardless?
Not generally but since in this case they had to record and hand over the IPs used to access the Proton Mail account, if he had used TOR they couldn’t have handed over anything useful