cross-posted from: https://lemmy.today/post/63107763
I’m looking for something like Snikket or Prosody, but kids-oriented. I DON’T want my <10 daughter using Meta Messenger Kids! I’ll tell my friends to setup for their kids, too. I’d have no access to anything, so it’s secure (mom and dad not snooping per se), but the downside is minimal parental controls. Though, no one to really add either.
I’ll host or pay for it, IDC. It doesn’t seem like there is much out there either.
JusTalk seemed nice when I found out but apparently China owned and so no more secure. I/we need better options!
TIL Meta Messenger Kids exists. Yikes.
Just building shadow profiles until they hit 13 to syphon the fuck out of everyone’s data!
I found out any pictures you upload to FB of your kids, each get their own profile, frequency they appear on your orioles, etc. They build massive profiles around these kids just to tie it all together later!
Source for this? I’m trying to convince grandparents to stop posting pics. It’s… Frustrating.
I’m not in the situation yet, but once i have kids I’ll tell my parents that, if i ever see a picture of my kids in any of those bs platforms (fb, Whatsapp…) they’ll never get another picture. parents have the ultimate decision about such things, if somebody else doesn’t respect your decision, they need to live with the consequences.
it might sound harsh, but seems to be the only really working strategy. i gave up explaining them stuff over a decade ago.
3 of the 4 are great about it, the 4th, while being careful (almost paranoid) about privacy, lives on Facebook and doesn’t get it, no matter what I’ve tried. We haven’t sent pictures in a long while.
Yes I have a couple sources. I hate to link a YT video, so I’ll use invidious. Both are great informative videos, but I don’t want to take up your time.
However, check this link first because it might be speculation without hard evidence, while other evidence points to them doing this exact thing but for adults or people 13+ https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20167085
Its at the very end at 10 minutes https://redirect.invidious.io/watch?v=Yv2Eb_kJous
Also here at 12:25 mark on the video https://redirect.invidious.io/watch?v=9wknq-Ra-KU
It’s worse than you think.
When I first looked t you couldn’t use it in the EU because it didn’t meet child protection laws.
I dont have a good suggestion, but you may unintentionally be about to give your daughter a brutal lesson in network effects. If all her friends end up using something else, she will be isolated.
As someone that went through Highschool when smart phones were first popular, it’s isolating being the only person not on instagram when everyone is using instagram (even if meta is bad).
It’s a tough decision but if privacy matters more, it’s going to be harder to connect with more people. Idk which country you are in so maybe alternatives are super popular.
Yeah, that’s exactly my point. I am not a parent, but in my opinion, it would be better to allow the use of whatever platform is the default, maybe provide an alternative, and give the child an age appropriate understanding of what using Instagram/Whatever means to them. “You can use it, but don’t say anything private like our address, because your private messages can be read by the company. If you need to say something private, use signal/matrix/whatever else, because that’s safe.”. Maybe if your lucky they can pass that knowledge to their friends as well.
Kids are walking privacy violations at the best of times anyway, education needs to start early.
Setup a private matrix instance
Second this. My friend group has been using my Matrix server for years.
I would love to see the success rate of getting the parents of the child’s friend to set up a matrix client for their child’s one friend that doesn’t use anything they do.
Help your child embrace not needing to be constantly in communication with her friends, to (gasp) use the phone … or accept and monitor the evil empires’ offerings but no matter what you do, don’t for one second think you’ll get a single family to set up a matrix client for “that one kid”.
Mayrix is awfully rough around the edges
Anyone ever use FluffyChat? That seems based on Matrix and cute like it’d be kid friendly. I’ll look more into matrix in general! TY
I use Fluffychat, it’s a nice app
Hell even the default one is better than everything else out there besides signal and xmpp. Don’t necessarily gotta host your own
As an alternative, around here, home phones (through voip) are making a comeback for kids.
Secure comms, no log, no photos, teaches a bit of etiquette.
Compatibility between self hosted and commercial systems.
You’re never going to get the other parents to fool with your messaging platform. Not because they don’t trust you, but because they simply can’t be bothered to. Normies have a bristling aversion to doing something different than they always have when it comes to apps/etc. I tried to get my friends on Signal, and gave up because they just wouldn’t.
Plus, the kids want to use what everyone else uses, creeps and trolls included.
Seriously I couldn’t even get my wife to use a third party messaging app.
Thank God iPhones finally support…RCS.
The problem is, if we fold on our kids, we are essentially just handing them over to meta. Forever. They will end up being as locked in and helpless as every other adult.
Facebook is the new smoking. Even worse. Because parents are now expected to put the cigarettes into their kids mouths themselves…and if they don’t? Your kid will be a social leper, and have the most miserable adolescence available.
Parents can’t even feign ignorance. We know how bad social media is…but we’re addicted. They’ve got dopamine on a treble hook right into our brains and they know it.
That’s not even teenage hyperbole. Like that’s legit what life is like for kids. No socials? May as well not exist.
Man I hope you’re wrong. Is there an aspect of modern life that isn’t absolutely fucked? Social media is toxic AF. Lemmy is the extent of what i can tolerate. I was a slave to FB for almost 20 years— I had a meme name and profile pic, but most folks knew who I was. I looked at my comments and post history and realized I was definitely on some watch lists, so I nuked the whole thing and haven’t been back. I miss marketplace - I have a bunch of junk I need to sell, but I don’t want to make a legit profile just on the chance I’ll get lured back in. I quit smoking the same way - got mad about it and stopped.
My oldest is 10 and he wants to be able to chat with his friends.
I sure as hell don’t want him on Facebook, yet that’s the most kid tested/mother approved out there.
I highly doubt my kid will have good luck getting his friends to join my private self-hosted matrix server.
Maybe one or two friends because their dads are my nerd friends. But that’s about it.
I don’t understand why nobody wants to just do email.
Email just always feels way too formal. With the addresses…and the subjects.
Messaging apps and SMS have always handled casual conversation so much better. Short-form async communication is best communication.
Maybe so. Either way self-hosting email is a huge PITA. Too bad every messaging option requires installing a (open source and sometimes clunky) app. I don’t mind it at all. I like shit that looks ancient as long as it works. Normies don’t have the patience/time/curiosity to set it up if it takes touching the screen more than 6 times.
I tried to get my friends on Signal, and gave up because they just wouldn’t.
Seems to vary on the particular “normies” as I haven’t had too much trouble. But I think anything more complicated than that is unlikely to fly with most people.